DIY Home Garden


Types of Cheddar Cheese (Every Home Cook Should Know These!)

Cheddar lovers unite!

Cheddar cheese is a beloved staple in culinary traditions. The cheese offers a wonderfully meltable blend of flavors, textures, and history. But how often have you wondered about the beginnings of cheddar or 

This article digs deeper into the fascinating world of cheddar cheese. By the end of this article, you will know:

  • The origins of cheddar cheese
  • Regional variations in the United States and Canada
  • Flavor characteristics of its various types
  • Why you find yellow and white cheddar cheese on grocery store shelves. 

Whether you’re a cheddar cheese aficionado or a curious food enthusiast, understanding the nuances of cheddar can elevate your culinary experiences.

The Rich History of Cheddar Cheese

Originating from the quaint village of Cheddar in Somerset, England, cheddar cheese has a storied history dating back to the 12th century. It gained popularity for its distinct aging process and robust flavor, becoming a staple in British cuisine. 

The 19th century saw cheddar’s global expansion. During that time, the United States and Canada became key cheese producers, each region adding its unique touch to the cheese-making craft.

Cheddar Cheese Across the United States and Canada

Wisconsin and Vermont are renowned for their cheddar production in the United States. Wisconsin, often called “America’s Dairyland,” has a rich cheese-making tradition. Cheddar has grown to become a prominent part of its dairy legacy. Vermont is known for its artisanal approach, often aging cheddar in special caves for distinct flavors.

Canada’s contributions to the cheddar scene are significant, with Quebec and Ontario at the forefront. Quebec’s cheddars are celebrated for their craftsmanship, often adhering to time-honored techniques, while Ontario is known for its large-scale, quality production.

garlic bread
Love my recipe for pull-apart cheddar garlic bread? Please pin it!

Exploring the Types of Cheddar Cheese: Mild, Sharp, and Extra Sharp 

Do you know the differences between mild, sharp, and extra sharp cheddar cheese? Read on to learn more. Who knew cheese making would be so intriguing?

Mild Cheddar

Mild cheddar ages for a relatively short period (two to three months). This cheddar has a famously creamy texture and subtle, buttery taste. It’s a versatile cheese, perfect for melting over dishes, adding to sandwiches, or incorporating mac and cheese into a smooth, gooey texture.

Sharp Cheddar

Aged longer, typically around nine months to a year, sharp cheddar offers a more pronounced flavor and slightly crumbly texture. It’s a great addition to cheese boards and baked dishes and is a robust flavor enhancer in soups and sauces.

Extra Sharp Cheddar

Extra sharp cheddar is aged the longest, often several years. This cheddar is for those who love a powerful cheese experience. Its intense flavor and firmer texture make it ideal for sophisticated culinary applications, from gourmet cheese platters to rich, flavorful sauces.

The Colorful World of Cheddar: Yellow vs. White

The color distinction between yellow and white cheddar stems from adding annatto, a natural dye from the achiote tree. White cheddar is the cheese in its natural state, while yellow cheddar gets its hue from this coloring. This addition doesn’t alter the flavor. Therefore, choosing yellow and white cheddar is a matter of visual preference rather than taste.

Cheddar Cheese and Wine Pairings: A Symphony of Flavors

Pairing cheddar cheese with the right wine can elevate your culinary experience. The key is to balance the cheese’s intensity with the wine’s characteristics. Here’s a guide to help you make the perfect cheddar and wine pairing:

Mild Cheddar Pairings

Mild cheddar, with its creamy and subtle flavor, pairs beautifully with lighter wines. A crisp, dry white wine like a nice Pinot Grigio or a Chardonnay with minimal oak influence complements its buttery texture without overwhelming the taste. A young and fruity Beaujolais or a light Pinot Noir can be delightful for red wine lovers.

Sharp Cheddar Pairings

The bolder flavor of sharp cheddar requires a wine that can match its intensity. A full-bodied Chardonnay with rich oak notes or a dry Riesling with its crisp acidity can stand up to the stronger taste of sharp cheddar. Red wine options include a Merlot with its soft tannins or a Zinfandel, which can handle the robustness of sharp cheddar.

Extra Sharp Cheddar Pairings

Extra sharp cheddar is most famous for its intense and complex flavors; it pairs well with deep, bold wines. A Cabernet Sauvignon, with its full body and firm tannins, complements the richness of the cheese. Alternatively, a robust Shiraz or a mature Bordeaux can create a harmonious balance with the strong character of extra sharp cheddar.

A Note on Port and Cheddar

For a classic pairing, try a vintage Port with any cheddar. Port’s sweet and rich profile creates a delightful contrast with the savory depth of cheddar, resulting in a luxurious taste experience.

Pairing cheddar cheese with the right wine is an art that enhances the flavors of both. From the light and creamy mild cheddars to the bold and intense extra-sharp varieties, there’s a wine pairing that can turn your cheese experience into a memorable gastronomic adventure. Next time you indulge in cheddar, consider accompanying it with a thoughtfully selected wine to discover the perfect flavor harmony.

grilled cheese sandwich

The Takeaway: Cheddar Cheese Has a Long History and Great Flavor

Cheddar cheese is a long-time favorite. It has a rich heritage and diverse flavors and textures. But it is more than just a culinary ingredient. Rather, it’s a journey through history and regional craftsmanship. There’s a cheddar for every palate and dish, from the mild, creamy varieties to the intensely flavorful aged ones. Whether it’s the artisanal cheddars from Vermont and Quebec or the traditional varieties from Wisconsin, cheddar cheese is cherished in North American kitchens.

As you explore the various types of cheddar cheese, remember that each brings its unique qualities to the table. So feel free to enjoy it in a comforting homemade dish or as part of an elegant cheese course. Either way, cheddar cheese promises to enhance your culinary creations with its delightful flavors.

If you loved this article about cheddar cheese, please follow our social media pages. We cover gardening, cooking, DIY, and more. You can connect with us on MeWe or on Facebook.

Scroll to Top